On 28 April 2004 CBS News's 60 Minutes II broadcast photographs showing US Army personnel at Abu Ghraib Prison in Iraq abusing Iraqi detainees — hooding, forced nudity, human pyramids, leashing. Army Specialist Joseph Darby had provided the photos to the Army Criminal Investigation Division in January 2004. Eleven enlisted soldiers were charged and courts-martialled; Charles Graner received 10 years, Lynndie England 3 years, Ivan Frederick 8 years. Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld offered his resignation, which President Bush refused. The Taguba Report (May 2004), the Schlesinger Panel, and the Fay-Jones Report documented systemic abuse and traced an interrogation-technique authorisation chain to OSD policy on SERE-derived 'enhanced' techniques. Senior leadership accountability was minimal.