RFK Jr. Anti-Vaccine Activism / Children's Health Defense (1998-present)
Introduction
Robert F. Kennedy Jr., environmental lawyer and son of Senator Robert F. Kennedy, has been one of the most prominent and persistent promoters of vaccine-skeptical claims in the United States for more than two decades. His central claims — that childhood vaccines cause autism and that thimerosal (a mercury-containing preservative formerly used in some vaccines) is responsible for a range of neurological harms — derive from sources that have been systematically investigated and refuted by the scientific and medical communities.
Kennedy's 2025 confirmation as US Secretary of Health and Human Services elevated the stakes of these claims from fringe advocacy to active federal health policy, making the factual record more consequential than at any previous point.
The Wakefield Foundation
The vaccine-autism claim originates primarily with Andrew Wakefield, a British gastroenterologist who published a study in The Lancet in February 1998 claiming a novel link between the MMR (measles-mumps-rubella) vaccine and autism in twelve children. The study generated enormous media coverage and contributed to vaccine hesitancy in the UK and United States.
Investigative journalist Brian Deer's decade-long investigation, published in the BMJ between 2004 and 2011, documented that Wakefield had manipulated and fabricated patient data, had been paid by a law firm seeking to sue vaccine manufacturers before the study was conducted, and had failed to disclose these financial relationships to The Lancet. The Lancet retracted the paper in full in February 2010. The UK General Medical Council found Wakefield guilty of serious professional misconduct and struck him off the medical register in May 2010. He is no longer licensed to practice medicine.
The Thimerosal Hypothesis
Kennedy's specific contribution to vaccine-skeptical advocacy focused on thimerosal, an ethylmercury-containing preservative used in some multi-dose vaccine vials. In 2005 he published a widely-circulated article in Rolling Stone and Salon (later substantially corrected and ultimately retracted by Salon) claiming a government cover-up of the vaccine-mercury connection.
The thimerosal hypothesis was addressed by the 2004 Institute of Medicine (IOM) report, which reviewed more than 200 epidemiological studies and found no causal link between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism. The Danish cohort study by Hviid et al. (2003, New England Journal of Medicine), following 530,000 children, found no increased risk of autism in children who received thimerosal-containing vaccines compared to those who did not.
Thimerosal was removed from routine childhood vaccines in the United States by 2001 as a precautionary measure. Autism diagnosis rates continued to rise after its removal, directly contradicting the prediction that thimerosal removal would reduce autism incidence.
Children's Health Defense
Kennedy founded the World Mercury Project in 2016, renamed Children's Health Defense (CHD) in 2018. CHD operates as a 501(c)(3) non-profit promoting vaccine-skeptical content and funding legal challenges to vaccine mandates. Reuters investigations published in February and August 2024 reported on CHD's finances, including substantial revenue growth during the COVID-19 pandemic, its fundraising methods, and the relationship between CHD's advocacy and Kennedy's political activities.
Policy Consequences
Kennedy's November 2024 nomination and 2025 confirmation as HHS Secretary made him one of the most senior health officials in the US government. In that role, questions about vaccine safety guidance, CDC advisory committee composition, and NIH funding priorities carry direct public health consequences. The scientific record on vaccine safety does not support the claims Kennedy has promoted, and public health bodies internationally have maintained consistent positions on vaccine efficacy and safety.
Verdict
Debunked. The vaccine-autism claim rests on a retracted, data-fabricated study by a struck-off physician. The thimerosal-mercury hypothesis was addressed by the 2004 IOM report and multiple large-scale epidemiological studies, none of which found a causal link. The removal of thimerosal from vaccines did not reduce autism rates. The scientific consensus on vaccine safety is not in dispute within the mainstream medical and epidemiological communities.
What Would Change Our Verdict
- A large-scale, pre-registered, independently replicated epidemiological study finding a causal link between MMR vaccination and autism
- Credible evidence of systematic suppression of data in the studies relied upon by regulatory bodies
- A mechanism plausibly linking aluminium adjuvants or other vaccine components to neurological harm at doses used in childhood immunisation schedules
Evidence Filters8
Wakefield 1998 Lancet paper retracted 2010 — data fabrication confirmed
DebunkingStrongThe Lancet retracted the original vaccine-autism paper in February 2010 after Brian Deer's investigation confirmed patient data had been manipulated and fabricated. The paper's retraction removes the primary evidentiary basis for the vaccine-autism claim.
Wakefield struck off the UK General Medical Council (May 2010)
DebunkingStrongThe GMC found Wakefield guilty of serious professional misconduct, including dishonesty and abuse of vulnerable patients. He is no longer licensed to practice medicine in the UK. The professional sanction is independent confirmation of the paper's fundamental invalidity.
2004 IOM report: no causal link between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism
DebunkingStrongThe Institute of Medicine reviewed more than 200 epidemiological studies and concluded there was no causal relationship between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism. This is the primary regulatory-body assessment of the thimerosal hypothesis Kennedy championed.
Hviid et al. 2003 (NEJM): n=530,000, no increased autism risk
DebunkingStrongThe Danish cohort study followed 530,000 children and found no increased risk of autism in those who received thimerosal-containing vaccines. It is one of the largest single epidemiological studies of the hypothesis and directly contradicts the thimerosal-mercury claim.
Thimerosal removed from childhood vaccines by 2001; autism rates continued rising
DebunkingStrongAs a precautionary measure, thimerosal was removed from routine US childhood vaccines by 2001. Autism diagnosis rates continued to increase after its removal, directly contradicting the causal prediction of the thimerosal hypothesis.
Wakefield had undisclosed financial conflicts with vaccine-litigation law firm
DebunkingStrongBefore publishing the 1998 Lancet paper, Wakefield had been retained and paid by a law firm seeking plaintiffs to sue vaccine manufacturers. The undisclosed financial relationship is the central ethical violation documented by Deer and the GMC.
Reuters investigations (Feb + Aug 2024) on CHD finances and methods
NeutralReuters published two investigations in 2024 examining Children's Health Defense's revenue growth, fundraising practices, and the relationship between CHD advocacy and Kennedy's political campaign activities. The investigations document the organisation's scale and methods.
Rebuttal
The CHD finance investigations document the organisation's growth and activities; they do not speak directly to the scientific claims. The vaccine-safety record stands independently on the epidemiological evidence, not on CHD's financial practices.
Vaccine-injury claims have generated sustained parental concern despite refutation
SupportingWeakDespite the scientific consensus, substantial parental concern about vaccine safety persists. Some parents report observing developmental changes following vaccination. The temporal association between vaccine timing and autism symptom onset (typically first observed around 12-18 months, similar to vaccination schedules) generates plausible-feeling but statistically unsupported causal attributions.
Rebuttal
Temporal association does not establish causation. Autism symptoms typically become observable at an age that overlaps with standard vaccination schedules regardless of whether vaccination occurs, producing spurious apparent correlations. Large-scale epidemiological studies controlling for confounders consistently find no causal link.
Evidence Cited by Believers1
Vaccine-injury claims have generated sustained parental concern despite refutation
SupportingWeakDespite the scientific consensus, substantial parental concern about vaccine safety persists. Some parents report observing developmental changes following vaccination. The temporal association between vaccine timing and autism symptom onset (typically first observed around 12-18 months, similar to vaccination schedules) generates plausible-feeling but statistically unsupported causal attributions.
Rebuttal
Temporal association does not establish causation. Autism symptoms typically become observable at an age that overlaps with standard vaccination schedules regardless of whether vaccination occurs, producing spurious apparent correlations. Large-scale epidemiological studies controlling for confounders consistently find no causal link.
Counter-Evidence6
Wakefield 1998 Lancet paper retracted 2010 — data fabrication confirmed
DebunkingStrongThe Lancet retracted the original vaccine-autism paper in February 2010 after Brian Deer's investigation confirmed patient data had been manipulated and fabricated. The paper's retraction removes the primary evidentiary basis for the vaccine-autism claim.
Wakefield struck off the UK General Medical Council (May 2010)
DebunkingStrongThe GMC found Wakefield guilty of serious professional misconduct, including dishonesty and abuse of vulnerable patients. He is no longer licensed to practice medicine in the UK. The professional sanction is independent confirmation of the paper's fundamental invalidity.
2004 IOM report: no causal link between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism
DebunkingStrongThe Institute of Medicine reviewed more than 200 epidemiological studies and concluded there was no causal relationship between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism. This is the primary regulatory-body assessment of the thimerosal hypothesis Kennedy championed.
Hviid et al. 2003 (NEJM): n=530,000, no increased autism risk
DebunkingStrongThe Danish cohort study followed 530,000 children and found no increased risk of autism in those who received thimerosal-containing vaccines. It is one of the largest single epidemiological studies of the hypothesis and directly contradicts the thimerosal-mercury claim.
Thimerosal removed from childhood vaccines by 2001; autism rates continued rising
DebunkingStrongAs a precautionary measure, thimerosal was removed from routine US childhood vaccines by 2001. Autism diagnosis rates continued to increase after its removal, directly contradicting the causal prediction of the thimerosal hypothesis.
Wakefield had undisclosed financial conflicts with vaccine-litigation law firm
DebunkingStrongBefore publishing the 1998 Lancet paper, Wakefield had been retained and paid by a law firm seeking plaintiffs to sue vaccine manufacturers. The undisclosed financial relationship is the central ethical violation documented by Deer and the GMC.
Neutral / Ambiguous1
Reuters investigations (Feb + Aug 2024) on CHD finances and methods
NeutralReuters published two investigations in 2024 examining Children's Health Defense's revenue growth, fundraising practices, and the relationship between CHD advocacy and Kennedy's political campaign activities. The investigations document the organisation's scale and methods.
Rebuttal
The CHD finance investigations document the organisation's growth and activities; they do not speak directly to the scientific claims. The vaccine-safety record stands independently on the epidemiological evidence, not on CHD's financial practices.
Timeline
Wakefield publishes vaccine-autism study in The Lancet
Andrew Wakefield and twelve co-authors publish a study in The Lancet claiming a novel MMR-autism link in twelve children. The study generates major media coverage and triggers lasting public concern about vaccine safety despite its tiny sample and methodological weaknesses.
Source →Hviid et al. NEJM study (n=530,000) finds no thimerosal-autism link
Danish researchers publish a cohort study of 530,000 children in the NEJM finding no increased autism risk in children who received thimerosal-containing vaccines, directly addressing the hypothesis Kennedy would champion.
Source →Lancet retracts Wakefield paper; GMC strikes Wakefield off register
The Lancet retracts the 1998 paper in full following Brian Deer's investigation confirming data fabrication and undisclosed financial conflicts. The UK GMC strikes Wakefield from the medical register for serious professional misconduct.
Source →RFK Jr. confirmed as US HHS Secretary
Following his November 2024 nomination by President Trump, Kennedy is confirmed as Secretary of Health and Human Services, bringing his vaccine-skeptical positions into active federal health policy.
Verdict
The vaccine-autism claim derives from the Wakefield 1998 Lancet paper, retracted 2010 after confirmed data fabrication; Wakefield struck off by the GMC. The thimerosal-mercury hypothesis was refuted by the 2004 IOM report and Hviid et al. 2003 (NEJM, n=530,000) among numerous subsequent studies. Autism rates rose after thimerosal removal, directly contradicting the hypothesis. No causal link between MMR vaccination and autism has been established in the peer-reviewed literature.
Frequently Asked Questions
Was there ever scientific support for a vaccine-autism link?
The sole peer-reviewed paper claiming a specific mechanism — Wakefield 1998 — was retracted in 2010 after confirmed data fabrication. No subsequent peer-reviewed study has established a causal link between MMR vaccination and autism. Multiple large-scale epidemiological studies have found no association.
Was thimerosal removed from childhood vaccines?
Yes. As a precautionary measure, thimerosal was removed from routine US childhood vaccines by 2001. Autism diagnosis rates continued to rise after its removal, which directly contradicts the prediction that removal would reduce autism incidence.
What is Children's Health Defense?
Children's Health Defense (formerly World Mercury Project) is a 501(c)(3) non-profit founded by Robert F. Kennedy Jr. that promotes vaccine-skeptical content and funds legal challenges to vaccine mandates. Reuters investigations in 2024 examined its finances and methods.
Why does vaccine hesitancy persist despite scientific consensus?
Several factors sustain vaccine hesitancy: the timing of autism symptom onset overlaps with vaccination schedules, creating plausible-feeling temporal associations; high-profile advocates with Kennedy-level credibility give the claims social legitimacy; and parental concern for children is a powerful motivator that epidemiological statistics do not easily displace. None of these factors constitute scientific evidence for the causal claims.
Sources
Show 3 more sources
Further Reading
- paperThimerosal and the occurrence of autism: negative ecological evidence (NEJM) — Anders Hviid et al. (2003)
- paperIOM 2004 Immunization Safety Review: Vaccines and Autism — Institute of Medicine (2004)
- articleWakefield's article linking MMR vaccine and autism was fraudulent (BMJ) — Brian Deer (2011)