Skip to main content

Fact check

Is it true: Abu Ghraib torture photographs (Apr 28 2004 CBS 60 Minutes II)?

Confirmed5% confidence

Yes — this is confirmed.

Eleven enlisted soldiers charged and courts-martialled; Charles Graner 10yr, Lynndie England 3yr, Ivan Frederick 8yr. Taguba Report: 'systemic and illegal abuse.' Schlesinger Panel and Fay-Jones Report documented SERE-derived technique authorisation chain to OSD. Rumsfeld offered resignation; Bush refused. No criminal charges against any officer above brigadier general. Joseph Darby provided photographs to CID January 2004.

The claim

On 28 April 2004 CBS News's 60 Minutes II broadcast photographs showing US Army personnel at Abu Ghraib Prison in Iraq abusing Iraqi detainees — hooding, forced nudity, human pyramids, leashing. Army

Key evidence

Rumsfeld offered resignation; Bush refused — no criminal charges for senior officials

Photographs authenticated; 11 soldiers convicted

Read the full evidence file

Conspirafy steelmans each claim, then follows the evidence. How we reach a verdict · Check another claim